You have the right to see the evidence the prosecution plans to use against you — and much more than that. This is how discovery works, what you're entitled to receive, how to ask for it, and what happens when the government doesn't comply.
Discovery is the process by which you obtain the evidence, documents, and information that the prosecution has — before trial. In criminal cases, the prosecution holds most of the evidence: police reports, lab results, witness statements, surveillance footage, prior criminal records, expert reports. Discovery gives you access to that material so you can prepare your defense.
Discovery rights in criminal cases come from two sources: constitutional guarantees and procedural rules. The constitutional floor is set by Brady v. Maryland and its progeny. State and federal procedural rules build on top of that and typically require broader disclosure.
As a pro se defendant, you have the same discovery rights as a represented defendant. Courts cannot give you less because you don't have a lawyer. What you won't have is an attorney who automatically requests discovery and chases down non-compliance — you have to do that yourself.
Under Brady v. Maryland (1963), the prosecution must disclose all evidence that is "material" to guilt or punishment and favorable to the defendant — even if you don't ask for it. This includes both exculpatory evidence (tending to show innocence) and impeachment evidence (tending to undermine witness credibility). Failure to disclose Brady material is a constitutional violation. The obligation is ongoing — it continues through trial and even after conviction if new material surfaces.
Giglio v. United States extended Brady to witness credibility. The prosecution must disclose any agreements or benefits given to prosecution witnesses in exchange for their testimony, as well as prior misconduct or perjury by those witnesses. For police witnesses specifically, this includes sustained complaints for dishonesty, prior false reports, and any prior judicial findings that the officer was not credible.
Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 16 and its state equivalents require broader disclosure than Brady alone. Under Rule 16 and comparable state rules, the prosecution must disclose: the defendant's prior statements, the defendant's criminal record, documents and tangible objects the government intends to use at trial, reports of examinations and tests, and expert witness summaries. Many states have even broader "open file" discovery policies. Check your state's criminal procedure rules for the specific requirements.
Request everything in this list, in writing, from the prosecution. Don't assume you'll automatically receive something just because you're entitled to it:
Discovery requests must be made in writing — never rely on a verbal request. Some jurisdictions have standardized discovery request forms; check your court's local rules. Where no form is required, write a formal letter or motion titled something like "Defendant's Request for Discovery and Disclosure."
Your name, case number, and the court it's filed in
Citation to the applicable rule (Federal Rule 16, or your state equivalent) and to Brady and Giglio by name
A specific, itemized list of what you are requesting — don't just say "all discovery." Itemized requests are harder to deny and easier to enforce
A response deadline — typically 14–21 days, or whatever your court's local rules require
Certificate of service confirming you sent a copy to the prosecution
File the request with the court clerk and serve a copy on the prosecutor. Keep your own file-stamped copy. In many jurisdictions, your discovery request is not a motion — you simply send it to the prosecution and file it with the court. In others, you must file a formal motion and set it for hearing. Check your local rules.
Non-compliance is common. Prosecutors have heavy caseloads, and discovery responses are often incomplete on the first round. Here's the escalation path:
Send a letter identifying what you requested, what you received, and what is still outstanding. Give a new deadline. Put it in writing so there's a record.
A motion to compel asks the court to order the prosecution to produce the materials you requested. Attach your original discovery request, any follow-up correspondence, and document what remains unproduced. Courts take compliance with discovery orders seriously.
If the court has ordered production and the prosecution still fails to comply, ask for sanctions: suppression of the undisclosed evidence, dismissal in egregious cases, or at minimum a continuance to give you time to review late-produced materials. Courts rarely dismiss cases outright but will suppress evidence that was improperly withheld.
If you discover after conviction that the prosecution withheld material Brady evidence, that is grounds for a new trial or appeal. Document every request you made and every instance of non-disclosure throughout the case — this record is what you'll rely on in a post-conviction Brady claim.
Once you have discovery, use Brief. Brief is designed for exactly this moment — upload your police report, lab reports, witness statements, and other discovery materials. Brief reads them together, identifies inconsistencies, flags the evidence most relevant to your defense, and shows you what questions your discovery raises so you know what to chase down next.
Upload your police report, lab results, witness statements, and other discovery documents. Brief identifies the key facts, flags inconsistencies between documents, and shows you what your discovery package is still missing.
Join the WaitlistEarly access. No credit card required.
The first document you'll receive in discovery — what every section means and what to look for.
The Faretta hearing, what the judge will ask, and how to formally take over your own defense.
Upload your discovery package. Brief identifies what matters, flags inconsistencies, and tells you what's still missing.